A new study of 125 years of Great Lakes weather and ice records points to a complicated future for Alpena and other communities along the lakes: ice cover has fallen sharply in recent decades, but the long-term record shows that freezing conditions have also moved through recurring cycles of increase and decline.

The study reconstructed changes in Great Lakes ice cover from 1898 through 2022. Researchers found that ice cover declined 10 times faster during the past 30 to 40 years than it did over the broader historical record. The findings were reported in a study examining historical air-temperature and ice data across the Great Lakes.

A file photo accompanying the report shows Alpena’s breakwall, harbor and Thunder Bay covered with ice, underscoring the local connection to a regional climate pattern that affects winter conditions, shoreline protection and lake activity.

Why the long-term record matters

Researchers said the decline cannot be explained by warming alone. Great Lakes ice cover has experienced repeated increases and decreases since 1898, influenced by several factors and by fluctuations that repeat roughly every 60 years.

To reconstruct past conditions, researchers used daily air-temperature records to determine how cold each winter was and how warm the preceding summer had been. The resulting record showed that ice-cover changes occurred against a backdrop of overall warming while also responding to longer-term climate variability.

Those changes were closely linked to the Atlantic Multidecadal Oscillation, or AMO, a climate indicator based on Atlantic Ocean surface temperatures. During warmer AMO phases, the Great Lakes had less ice; during colder phases, they had more. Researchers said the lakes are influenced by climate conditions from both the Atlantic and Pacific oceans.

“The 60-year cycle means that over the last 100-plus years, there have been periods when ice cover decreased, followed by periods when it increased or, at least, remained about the same,” Cannon said.

David Cannon, a researcher at the Cooperative Institute for Great Lakes Research at the University of Michigan and one of the study’s lead authors, said the record shows that ice cover did not move constantly in one direction. Instead, it passed through recurring periods of increase and decline.

What less ice could mean for Alpena

Ice cover affects more than the appearance of Alpena’s harbor and shoreline during winter. The study said ice on large lakes helps regulate regional weather and aquatic ecosystems, making the findings relevant to environmental management.

When the lakes are covered, ice can protect shorelines from waves generated by strong winter storms. It can help prevent coastal erosion, and researchers said there is evidence that some fish species rely on ice cover to protect spawning habitats.

“When the lakes are covered with ice, they are more protected from waves generated by strong winter storms,” Cannon said.

The findings also matter for activities and industries tied to the Great Lakes. Cannon said fisheries, shipping and recreation all rely on ice in some capacity, meaning changes in winter ice conditions could affect how communities use and manage the lakes.

The study also examined differences among the individual Great Lakes. Researchers were especially surprised by Lake Ontario, where maximum ice cover over the past 40 years was about 20%. The model showed that Lake Ontario has historically been a lake with relatively little ice cover, even though direct records from 100 years ago are not available.

What researchers plan to study next

The current analysis estimates the overall ice cover of each of the five Great Lakes rather than showing how ice is distributed within individual bays or other areas. Cannon said researchers hope to apply the approach to smaller regional areas in the future.

That could eventually allow researchers to examine historical ice conditions in places such as Green Bay or Saginaw Bay and explore how those changes affected the way people used the lakes. For Alpena, more detailed regional analysis could provide a clearer picture of how broad Great Lakes trends relate to local shoreline, harbor and fisheries conditions.

The researchers said the work will also help climate scientists distinguish century-scale changes associated with global climate change from shorter-term variability. Their results suggest that the pace of ice-cover loss could slow, at least temporarily, during the next several decades—even as the longer-term record shows substantial recent decline.