How Michigan residents view plants and animals can change as new evidence reshapes understanding of their role in the natural world. In a column for The Alpena News, Dr. Greg Corace, forest and wildlife ecologist for the Alpena-Montmorency Conservation District, uses gray wolves and several nonnative tree and plant species to illustrate why land management decisions may need to evolve.

The gray wolf offers one of the clearest examples. Human actions extirpated wolves from mainland Michigan by the middle of the 20th century, when many people broadly viewed them as dangerous, bloodthirsty animals. As the population recovered decades later, research documented the wolf’s role as a keystone species in ecosystems.

Corace notes that predation is an important process in regulating prey populations, even though Michiganders continue to hold differing opinions about wolves. The example shows why species are not always simply beneficial or harmful; their effects can depend on their place in an ecosystem.

From promoted plant to management problem

Autumn olive demonstrates how quickly attitudes toward a nonnative plant can change. During the late 20th century, federal, state and local agencies, along with nonprofits and special-interest groups, promoted the shrub to stabilize soil and provide fruit for wildlife.

Autumn olive did both, but it also aggressively competed with native plants for growing space. As a result, more time and money may now be spent controlling its dominance than were originally spent promoting its establishment. A plant once considered useful became widely disliked within a few decades.

Lessons from a century-old tree plantation

Scots pine, also called Scotch pine, may be following a less dramatic version of that pattern. The nonnative Eurasian species was planted in Michigan at least as early as the 1880s at the W.J. Beal Tree Plantation in Grayling. The plantation was named for the professor who planted stems from 41 tree species, including 16 nonnative species, to study their growth on the area’s sandy, drought-prone soils.

When researchers examined the plantation and an adjoining old field more than 100 years later, between 1998 and 2000, none of the 32 planted deciduous trees had survived. Eastern white pine and red pine grew well, but Scots pine and Norway spruce had regenerated away from the plantation in the old field, showing invasive tendencies.

The study authors urged caution when planting nonnative trees and recommended managing them, where possible, to limit their abundance and spread into native ecosystems.

What land managers can do

Corace writes that Scots pine and Norway spruce do not vigorously resprout. Where reducing their abundance is a goal, they can be cut below their lowest branches at ground level and left to die over time.

In areas containing mature trees, saplings and seedlings, managers can begin at the edge of an infestation and work inward. Another option is to remove the most mature trees first to limit seed production, then cut the youngest seedlings.

Future planning, Corace concludes, should learn from past treatments and rely on the best available science. Native plants are generally the preferred choice for artificial regeneration, but selections should also reflect landowner goals, ecosystem type, soil texture, moisture and the site’s present and future climate.

Corace said he can provide information about the Qualified Forest Program and related forest planning and management through the Alpena-Montmorency Conservation District at [email protected].