Alpena Public Schools could receive state funding for school safety and student mental health, but Superintendent Dave Rabbideau told the Board of Education and community members that restrictions tied to the safety money remain a concern. He also warned that a separate transportation program supporting the district is scheduled to run out at the end of this year.

Rabbideau discussed the funding issues Monday during an APS Board of Education workshop meeting. The topics included Michigan's 31AA safety and mental health funds and 22(l) transportation funding, which has helped offset the cost of operating transportation services across the district's large rural area.

Why APS has hesitated over safety funding

The board decided last year not to accept the 31AA safety funds. Rabbideau said accepting the money would require people connected with the district to give up certain due process rights if a mass-casualty event occurred.

Under Section 31AA of Michigan's State School Aid Act, a district accepting the funds could face a “comprehensive investigation” after a mass-casualty incident and would waive privileges that might otherwise protect the disclosure of applicable information. Rabbideau said district legal counsel and multiple Michigan law firms viewed that requirement as unreasonable for board members, administrators and school personnel.

The safety funding remains an option for APS during the current school year. If the board declines it, the district would not need to take formal action. If accepted, the money could support school resource officers, threat-assessment training for staff, firearm-safety education for students and families, safety infrastructure and other related needs. The allocation would be $147.06 per student.

Rabbideau said the state has narrowed the definition of a mass-casualty event this year, but he believes the wording remains unclear. One definition covers an incident causing significant physical injuries to at least three people on school grounds or at a school-sponsored event.

“It's just not defined well enough for us to feel comfortable about it,” Rabbideau said.

He offered a football-game example in which three students tripping down the stairs could potentially meet that definition. Other parts of the definition cover an incident involving at least two fatalities or an emergency so extensive that local response resources are insufficient and outside jurisdictions must help.

Rabbideau said APS has participated for about four years in monthly or quarterly safety meetings with districts in the Alpena Montmorency Alcona Educational Service District, emergency medical officials and local sheriffs. Those discussions have focused on preparing for incidents requiring a response from multiple jurisdictions.

“The whole point was we knew it was going to be a multi-jurisdiction response to any elevated incident,” he said.

He said that if a large-scale event occurred, Alpena would not be the only jurisdiction responding, potentially raising questions about how the state's definition would apply.

Mental health funding has fewer restrictions

This year's 31AA program separates mental health funding from safety funding. Rabbideau said he wants the district to pursue the mental health allocation because it does not carry the same restrictions.

The money could help pay for counselors, social workers and other positions, along with student programs that assess or track mental well-being. APS would receive $73.53 per student for mental health funding.

Rabbideau described that money as a simpler option for the district. The Board of Education does not need to vote to accept it; administrative staff must apply before the application window closes in November.

Transportation funding may end after this year

Rabbideau also reviewed 22(l) transportation aid, a program created after Michigan recognized the transportation challenges facing northern Michigan and rural school districts. The program set aside $128 million for statewide distribution to districts with high transportation costs.

APS has received approximately $550,000 to $560,000 annually through the program. That money represents about one-quarter of the district's transportation budget, according to Rabbideau.

The state fund is expected to be depleted by the end of 2026, making this the final year APS will receive the funding unless state legislators include additional support in a future budget cycle. No board action was required on the transportation issue because the presentation was informational.

Rabbideau used the district's size to illustrate the challenge. APS covers 605 square miles, while 85 of Michigan's smallest districts combined would cover about 590 square miles, he said.

“School finance is complex and what you have one day you might not have the next,” Rabbideau said.