Alpena Public Schools is weighing a proposed $29 million bond package that would pay for renovations and upgrades at facilities across the district without increasing the current debt-millage rate, if voters approve the plan.
Representatives of IDI and Clark Construction Company presented a final preliminary list of projects during a Monday Alpena Public Schools Board of Education workshop meeting. The list followed a facilities study and four weeks of community input. The proposal was first introduced at a June 15 workshop meeting.
If the Board of Education decides to proceed, the proposal would be placed on the May ballot. The source does not identify the year of that May election, although it later refers to a possible 2027 bond proposal.
How the proposed millage would work
The proposed bond is described as a no-mill-increase plan because the district would keep its existing 1.8-mill debt levy if voters approve it. That levy currently pays off the district’s 2020 “safe, warm, dry” bond, which provided approximately $34 million for upgrades across APS facilities. Work from that bond began in summer 2021, and the main work was completed in summer 2025 with renovations at Alpena High School.
The district’s existing debt millage is expected to fall from 1.8 mills to 1 mill after the 2026 debt levy. If the Board of Education pursues a 2027 bond and voters approve it, the debt levy would remain at 1.8 mills until 2037. Debt from both bonds would be paid off by 2052, according to the information presented to the board.
Elementary school priorities
The preliminary project list emphasizes building systems, safety, energy savings and infrastructure. At Ella White Elementary, proposed work includes replacing the fire alarm for $264,539 and upgrading the façade and adding block infill for long-term energy savings at an estimated $1,170,637.
Besser Elementary’s proposed work includes window replacement at $637,480, a sewer-line replacement at $407,830, exterior doors at $285,481, and HVAC air-handling and exhaust improvements at $644,372. Hinks Elementary is listed for exterior window replacement costing $248,369 and façade upgrades estimated at $1,268,516.
At Lincoln Elementary, the priorities are a fire-alarm replacement costing $184,462 and replacement of the clock and public-address system for $134,674. Sanborn Elementary is listed for exterior window replacement at $328,793 and classroom HVAC replacement at $1,292,007.
Sunset Elementary would receive a roof-system replacement estimated at $953,565. The list also includes classroom HVAC equipment and controls, a fire-alarm upgrade, exterior door and window improvements, and a new clock and public-address system. The costs for those additional Sunset projects were marked to be determined.
Wilson Elementary is listed for exterior window replacement at $140,742 and kitchen and classroom HVAC work estimated at $1,407,831.
Secondary schools, transportation and athletics
The largest individual project identified in the preliminary list is at Alpena High School: replacement of windows and storefront assemblies, estimated at $6,787,563. The high school priorities also include exterior doors at $727,977 and installation of a lift at each house for Americans with Disabilities Act compliance, estimated at $228,385.
Thunder Bay Junior High School would receive a site reconfiguration estimated at $1,327,896 and a replacement clock and public-address system costing $407,144.
The Transportation Center priorities include an upgrade to vehicle exhaust, vehicle-wash equipment and improvements to the staff lounge, restroom and office area. The staff-area work is listed at $439,054. The source lists the vehicle-wash work together with the exhaust cost rather than giving it a separate amount.
Alpena Athletics is included in the proposal with a $114,193 gymnasium lift for accessibility. The list also calls for a $3,670,474 training-facility addition intended to eliminate the existing basement locker-room condition.
At the Central Office, the proposed work includes a façade upgrade estimated at $931,811, exterior window replacement at $282,850, a fire-alarm replacement at $114,193, and a new clock and public-address system at $92,659.
Adding the listed amounts produces a preliminary total of $24,681,099, not including the Sunset Elementary projects whose costs remain undetermined. That total is therefore below the proposed $29 million bond amount.
Residents offered broader spending scenarios
Community members also developed alternative approaches during the final forum on Nov. 9. One group focused on project categories rather than individual buildings. Its list added projects that were not included in the initial priorities, including an Alpena High School auditorium renovation and replacement of doors, windows and fire-alarm systems at all schools needing that work. The group’s scenario totaled $28,702,657.
A second group created two additional scenarios. The first added clock and public-address systems at schools not included in the priority list, along with an Alpena High School auditorium renovation, bringing the total to $31,189,190. The second used the priority list and added bathroom and science-lab upgrades at Alpena High School, for a total of $28,677,837.
Craig Carmoney, an educational consultant with IDI, told board members that the bond should reflect what the community needs and wants its schools to become.
“You really have to know your community in terms of 'Yep, this sounds and looks like us' versus this sounds and looks like, for example, 'Oh, that sounds more like another district that they're all about doing something more glamorous,' like they have to do that,”
Board Member Eric Hansen asked whether the community’s priorities matched what engineers considered most urgent. Carmoney said residents wanted the plan to address critical end-of-life items while also including projects that could build enthusiasm.
“The group that I was listening to really felt strongly that we've got to do a little bit to get people a little bit excited about some of this stuff as well, so science classrooms for example,”
Carmoney added that the proposed plan addresses the most necessary aging systems.
“As far as end of life items, we are covering what you need to have covered during this bond,”
Board and Treasury steps remain
The community feedback is expected to help the district prepare the bond project’s scope and a Pre-Qualifying Application, or PQA, for the Michigan Department of Treasury. The source said the project scope had to be completed by the following Monday so the application could be prepared.
A meeting with the Department of Treasury was scheduled for Dec. 16, followed by a Dec. 21 Board of Education meeting to consider approval of the PQA. Board President Eric Lawson said the board would seek consensus on the bond’s general direction and priorities at the next regular board meeting, then finalize the plan with a vote in December.
Even if the board advances the proposal, the bond would still require voter approval before the work could proceed.