A defense motion challenging a search warrant is now before the court as an Alpena County criminal case involving allegations of criminal sexual conduct moves toward a January trial.

Aaron Pokorzynski, 37, appeared Monday in the 26th Circuit Court in Alpena. The hearing focused on a recently filed pre-trial motion and other motions his defense may pursue. Pokorzynski is charged with second-degree criminal sexual conduct and three counts of first-degree criminal sexual conduct.

The first-degree charges involve allegations that Pokorzynski had sexual intercourse with a 15-year-old child in 2012 while serving as the child’s tennis instructor at the APlex. The second-degree charge concerns a separate 2021 incident involving another person for whom he was also an instructor.

Defense motion challenges search warrant

Attorney Gary Springstead told the court he filed a motion Monday and sent it to the prosecutor’s office and the court. The motion challenges the particularity of the search warrant.

Springstead also said he may file additional motions involving Michigan Rule of Evidence 404(b), which concerns the use of evidence of prior acts. Other possible motions would seek a more specific statement of the alleged events’ time frame and challenge references to the person described in the case as the “victim,” rather than the “accuser” or “complainant.”

The defense attorney also raised possible limits on hearsay and testimony based on a person’s own knowledge of an event. He said he believed there was substantial rumor and innuendo and might seek a motion in limine, which asks the court to set limits on evidence or arguments before trial.

Generally, evidence of prior acts cannot be introduced simply to show a defendant’s character. The source said Rule 404(b) can allow such evidence for purposes including motive, opportunity, intent, preparation, plan, knowledge, identity, or the absence of mistake or accident.

Earlier motions and January trial date

The case’s trial was first set for Jan. 13 before being moved to Oct. 13 after Pokorzynski’s former attorney, Matt Wojda, filed an application for leave to appeal. That filing paused further hearings while the Michigan Court of Appeals considered whether to hear the appeal. The application was ultimately denied.

Pokorzynski changed attorneys on June 3, according to court records. Springstead is based in Fremont, Michigan.

Judge Ed Black said he was not moving the January trial date unless the attorneys agreed to a change. The trial is currently scheduled for Jan. 26 through Jan. 29.

Black told the defense that any motions needed to be filed “pronto.” Alpena County Assistant Prosecuting Attorney Alyssa Miller said the court had previously set Sept. 21 as the deadline for motions. She said no motions had been filed when the parties appeared in court Sept. 8 and that motions were expected to be addressed at Monday’s hearing.

Miller also said the court had already denied an earlier motion concerning references to the victim. She said another motion seeking admission of previous acts had been granted in part. Springstead said he would check with Pokorzynski’s prior attorney to determine which motions had already been filed.

Pokorzynski’s next hearing is scheduled for 2:30 p.m. Dec. 7.