A felony assault case in Alpena County is taking a new procedural turn after defendant Shaun Lozen retained a new attorney and his defense filed motions involving seized property and a video of his preliminary examination.
Lozen, 46, appeared Monday in the 26th Circuit Court for his second hearing since being bound over from the 88th District Court following a preliminary examination. His next hearing is scheduled for 1:15 p.m. Feb. 16 in the 26th Circuit Court.
Charges include assault and domestic violence
Lozen is charged with two counts of assault with intent to murder, five counts of assault with intent to do great bodily harm less than murder involving strangulation, and one count of interfering with electronic communications. He also faces one count of aggravated domestic violence and four counts of domestic violence.
During the August preliminary examination, the alleged victim testified about multiple alleged physical assaults, including strangulation, over the course of a relationship that prosecutors said lasted about five years. The Alpena News does not identify victims of alleged domestic violence.
At an earlier hearing, Alpena County Assistant Prosecuting Attorney Alyssa Miller and Lozen’s previous defense attorneys, Deanna Kelley and David Kramer, discussed an agreement to search the alleged victim’s cellphone.
The proposed search covered communications between the alleged victim and Lozen, photographs of the pair, phone recordings, photographs of alleged injuries, communications with police about the investigation and messages the alleged victim allegedly sent to three women to warn them about Lozen.
New attorney asks for property and video
Since that hearing, Lozen has retained John Tosto, a defense attorney based in Flint. Tosto filed one motion seeking the return of seized property and another requesting a digital video copy of the preliminary examination.
Miller told the court that, with the exception of one cellphone considered to have evidentiary value, the seized property was available to be returned to Lozen. Tosto said he understood that prosecutors had already extracted data from the phone and asked that it be returned as well.
“How can I return a phone when it is part of the evidentiary value of the case,”
Judge Ed Black asked. Tosto replied, “I understand Judge, that's our request.”
Black said returning the phone could create problems for the prosecution, depending on whether the defense agreed to sign a waiver. The court also discussed possible future issues involving the preservation and collection of evidence.
The phone is expected to be processed by the Computer Crime Unit. Miller said it was delivered to Alpena Police on Nov. 5 and will be taken to the laboratory the next time an officer transports evidence there.
Court weighs access to preliminary-examination video
Tosto also asked to receive a digital copy of the preliminary-examination video. Black said the 88th District Court’s procedure is to provide transcripts rather than video copies, although counsel could go to the district court to watch the recording.
“That would be contrary to what the district court's policy is,”
Black said. Tosto said he had not known viewing the video at the district court was an option.
Tosto told the court that watching the examination alongside the transcript, which the defense already had received, would help attorneys evaluate the credibility of the alleged victim and prepare for a possible resolution or trial.
“It would be very beneficial for us to view the exam hearing in conjunction with the transcript, which we've already been provided,”
Tosto said.
Black initially denied the motion without prejudice, saying he needed to research the district court’s policy. He later changed the order to provisionally grant Tosto authority to obtain a copy, while allowing the court seven days to contact the district court and verify why the policy is in place.
If the video is provided, it may remain only in the custody of defense counsel and cannot be distributed to anyone else. Black also said his understanding from Lozen’s prior attorneys was that the case was “destined for trial.”
The proceedings concern allegations that remain unresolved in court. Lozen’s next appearance will determine the next step as the court continues addressing the evidence and discovery issues raised by the defense.