For people dating in Alpena and across Northeast Michigan, meeting someone can now begin with a swipe, a message or a phone call. But residents and Hope Shores Alliance representatives say online dating has also brought harder questions about consent, safety, emotional connection and where people can meet away from a screen.

The shift from early online chat rooms and dating websites to apps such as Tinder and Bumble has changed how people form relationships. Jeanine Kaltz, prevention and outreach coordinator for Hope Shores Alliance, said young people need to understand that boundaries apply online just as they do in person.

“Online dating etiquette is challenging to teach,” Kaltz said, adding that young people need to respect the same boundaries online as they do in real life.

Consent and artificial intelligence add new concerns

Kaltz said online behavior can be difficult to categorize, particularly when people send unwanted sexual images or interact intensely with someone’s social-media history. She questioned where conduct falls between flirting and harassment, asking, “Is sending pictures of your genitalia, is that flirting? Is that sexual assault?”

She also warned that artificial intelligence could make relationships more complicated as more young men seek advice, emotional support or connection from AI systems. Kaltz said she is concerned about a future in which people rely on systems designed to make users feel good rather than offering mutual human interaction or meaningful challenge.

Tressa Snider, Hope Shores Alliance’s advocacy services coordinator, said parenting a teenager in today’s dating environment can be difficult because online access removes some of the separation young people once had from their peers. “I'm a parent of a teenager in high school and I'm lost,” Snider said.

Both advocates also pointed to a lack of places for young people and singles to gather. Kaltz said she was surprised when young people identified Walmart as a place to spend time, while Snider questioned where people could go if online dating was not the preferred option.

Alpena residents describe inconsistent connections

Mathew Nelson, a 21-year-old Alpena resident who works in management at Culver’s and Besser Senior Living, said online dating can create attachment before a person suddenly disappears or changes how they communicate. He said the most difficult part is often not getting matches but finding consistency afterward.

Nelson said messaging can reveal how someone communicates and what interests them, but meeting in person remains essential because a chat does not show a person’s voice, reactions or what it feels like to spend ordinary time together. He said he wants a relationship built around mutual interest rather than quick attention, validation or convenience.

He also said dating apps can make people seem replaceable because users are constantly shown another profile or possible match. Nelson would like to see more community events, hobby groups, outdoor activities and other social spaces that are not centered on drinking or explicitly labeled as dating events.

Brianna Brown, a 34-year-old Alpena resident and mother, said only a small number of online connections develop into dates. She said safety and her children affect how she approaches in-person meetings, with first dates held in public and potential dates researched before meeting.

Brown said she checks names to determine whether a person is a registered sex offender and described the dating-app environment as frustrating. She also wants more alcohol-free or free events for singles, such as dances. In her view, local options include churches, bowling alleys, diners and restaurants, but few other gathering places.

Jesse Huizenga, a 34-year-old Alpena resident, said his online interactions have mostly involved sporadic chatting rather than in-person relationships. He said people should meet online connections in public and suggested that locations such as the APlex or Art in the Loft could potentially host social events, although he was unsure how large the turnout would be.

Some Northeast Michigan relationships began online

Not every experience has been negative. Katie DesOrmeau, 38, lives in Lincoln and works in Alpena. She said her online dating experience was mixed, but she met her fiancé on Tinder five years ago. After seeing his photos and talking with him, they went to Mangos and then walked to a park and played on the swings near the bandshell.

DesOrmeau said the relationship worked because he appeared interested in a serious partnership rather than a hookup. She said online dating gave her a way to meet someone she otherwise might not have encountered after moving back to Northeast Michigan.

Faith Disch, a 25-year-old Alpena resident, also said she became engaged to someone she met through a dating app. She cautioned that people should research an online connection before meeting, tell someone where they are going and make sure another person knows their location.

Michael Kohler, a 46-year-old Hillman resident who is new to Northeast Michigan, said he has found relatively few potential matches and had not been on a date through online dating. He recommends a phone call before meeting because a conversation can reveal important information. He said people can find local bars, parks and places to walk, but he has struggled to discover a broader community.

Danielle Edmonds, an Alpena resident who has used dating websites and apps for 14 years, said she is increasingly interested in meeting people in real life. As a member of the LGBTQ+ community, she said dating in public can feel intimidating, but online connections can also feel less present than relationships formed face to face.

The experiences shared by Alpena-area residents point to a tension that is unlikely to disappear: dating apps can connect people who might never meet otherwise, but many residents still want more welcoming, accessible places to build relationships in person.