For nearly 25 years, Tubby’s was one of Alpena’s best-known gathering places for teenagers, college students, families and anyone looking for a meal at 132 South Second Avenue. Located only a few blocks from Alpena High School, the family restaurant became part of daily life for students from Alpena High School, Catholic Central High School and Alpena Community College.

Tubby’s is now gone, but its history remains tied to the changing face of downtown Alpena. The restaurant was demolished during the late 1970s redevelopment that created the community plaza, leaving former customers with memories of burgers, jukeboxes, affordable Cokes and crowded lunch hours.

From an orchestra nickname to a South Second Avenue restaurant

Howard and Rita Rigg established Tubby’s in 1950. The couple had moved to Alpena from Ohio, where Howard performed as a drummer and vocalist with the Benny Bowman Orchestra. The orchestra played in the ballroom that once stood above Alpena Furniture.

The restaurant took its name from Howard Rigg’s nickname from his orchestra days. According to an account by the couple’s son, Bobby, Howard first opened Tubby’s in a small building on South Second Avenue. He later reached an agreement with Alpena businessperson Howard French to design and build a larger restaurant to his specifications.

When the expanded Tubby’s opened, French operated an adjacent record and music store. Inside, customers found a cash register near the entrance, a long counter with dining stools, chrome tables and chairs, booths, and a kitchen at the rear. Each booth had a small jukebox selector, while a larger jukebox played popular 45-rpm records.

The restaurant operated from 6 a.m. to 8 p.m. every day except Sunday. Its menu included standard family-restaurant fare and three or four daily specials. One distinctive offering was fried perch caught and prepared by Howard Rigg’s father. Bobby also recalled that his father cut and prepared a variety of meats according to his own specifications.

A restaurant built around students and families

Tubby’s was not only a place for meals. It became a regular meeting spot for high school and college students, and all four of the Rigg children worked there. As business grew, Howard opened the adjacent Snack Shack, a smaller restaurant aimed specifically at students.

The Snack Shack had a limited menu of hamburgers, hot dogs, French fries, ice cream shakes, malts, Cokes and other soft drinks. Bobby said his father moved him from dishwashing at Tubby’s to operate the smaller restaurant.

Former customers remembered the restaurant as a place where school groups, friends and families crossed paths. Ellen Eagan recalled that pizza still seemed unfamiliar to many Alpena residents in the 1950s. Kim Pfeiffer remembered visiting Tubby’s with her second-grade class from Avery School for a breakfast-food-pyramid field trip, when students were expected to dress formally.

“Pizza was an exotic foreign food that few people in Alpena had eaten in the 1950’s, unless they lived, studied, or vacationed on the East coast.”

Susie Martin remembered Catholic Central students riding in the back of a friend’s pickup truck to meet at Tubby’s, the Snack Shack and the nearby record store. Other memories focused on the restaurant’s low prices and distinctive atmosphere. Marilyn Berglin recalled that Cokes cost 10 cents, while a cherry Coke cost 12 cents.

The restaurant also reflected the dining habits of its era. A cigarette vending machine stood inside, and ashtrays were placed at the tables, booths and counter. Diane Heise, who worked at Tubby’s, recalled starting at the dishwasher and described the kitchen’s sinks, potato peeler, steam table, stove, ovens and preparation tables.

How Tubby’s disappeared from downtown

Howard Rigg operated Tubby’s until 1965, according to Alpena News accounts and the family’s recollections. He then traded the restaurant operation to a new owner in exchange for a restaurant and bowling alley in Hillman, Michigan.

The business continued under the Tubby’s name until the new owner renamed it Great Lakes Café in mid-1980. Howard later owned and operated a Stroh’s ice cream parlor and the Hide-A-Way tavern and restaurant on U.S. 23 north.

The physical restaurant disappeared before that later name change. In 1978, the City of Alpena purchased the Culligan building at Chisholm and Second for $165,000. By the end of 1979, the building and many adjacent Second Avenue buildings had been demolished to make way for downtown’s community plaza.

Former Alpena High faculty member Tom Atkinson remembered finding Tubby’s packed with upperclassmen during a one-hour lunch break in 1968. He and two classmates left almost immediately because of the smoke, choosing custard rolls and milk at Climie’s Bakery instead. Even that memory underscores Tubby’s role in Alpena: for some, it was a favorite lunch stop; for others, it was an unmistakable part of the town’s school-day landscape.