Alpena’s history has a darker, more mysterious side. A Visit Alpena guide explores haunted places, urban legends and folklore connected to lighthouses, theaters, restaurants, parks and historic sites across the region.
The stories range from reports of a light glowing in a decommissioned lighthouse to tales of a ghostly theater visitor and a bar stool pulled away from an otherwise orderly row. They are presented as local stories and legends rather than verified supernatural events.
Haunted places in and around Alpena
Old Presque Isle Lighthouse
Constructed in 1840, Old Presque Isle Light was the first lighthouse in the Presque Isle area. It operated for 31 years before being decommissioned.
The best-known story centers on George Parris, who later cared for the lighthouse grounds with his wife, Lorraine. After George died in 1992, the amber light at the top of the tower was said to glow from dusk until dawn—even though the wiring had been removed in 1979.
One visiting child reportedly told her parents that a man at the top of the tower was making her laugh. After seeing a photograph in the museum next to the lighthouse, she identified the man as George Parris.
Thunder Bay Theatre
Located in Alpena’s Old Town district, Thunder Bay Theatre is associated with stories about a ghost named “Aggie.” Actors and production crew members reportedly say Aggie is mischievous rather than threatening.
According to the stories, costumes and props that cannot be found sometimes turn up the next day in places that seem conspicuously obvious. The guide also says Aggie is particularly noticeable to people who do not believe in ghosts.
Ghost Village of Bell
The Ghost Village of Bell is located in the Besser Bell Natural Area. Evidence of the former settlement includes a small cemetery, a remaining chimney, collapsed walls and a bronze dedication plaque.
People claim the area is haunted by the spirits of Native Americans and former residents of Bell. The guide invites readers to share their own stories about the site.
Sacred Rock
Sacred Rock is described as a boulder about six miles north of Hoeft Park outside Rogers City. It measures approximately six feet tall and 12 feet wide.
One legend says two rival Native American chiefs were arguing over hunting grounds when the Great Spirit threw the rock down, crushing and burying them. Another version says lightning killed the chiefs while they argued over territorial boundaries. Some people say the rock appears to “bleed” when rain falls.
Stories from downtown restaurants and theaters
The Court Yard
Servers at The Court Yard, an Alpena fine-dining restaurant, have reported their own unexplained experiences. One server said she saw a man wearing a top hat sitting at a table while preparing the restaurant before opening. When she approached, he was gone.
Another story involves a regular customer who had died. A bartender reportedly heard a wind chime at the entrance and a bar stool scrape across the floor. When she returned to the bar, no one was there, but one stool had been pulled out where the customer usually sat.
Thunder Bay Lighthouse
According to local lore, Thunder Bay Lighthouse is haunted by “Morgan,” a former keeper who supposedly died of loneliness. The story says Morgan continues to roam the shoreline of Thunder Bay Island and can be heard walking the stairs as if carrying out keeper duties.
The former State Theater
The former State Theater, another historic downtown Alpena building, is linked to reports from a former employee who was closing around 2 a.m. The employee said a bathroom stall door appeared to close with fingers pulling it shut.
After waiting outside for about 20 minutes, the employee called out but heard no response. When the bathroom was checked, the stall door was open and nobody was inside. The building is also associated with stories of a little girl appearing above the marquee, which was later removed during renovations.
Folklore beyond the city
Negwegon State Park
Visit Alpena describes Negwegon State Park as a rustic area with a long Native American history. No specific haunting is identified, but fishermen and campers have described feeling uneasy there at night. The guide connects that feeling to the area’s history as the location of a Native American burial ground.
The Alpena ghost ship
The bonus story concerns a ship that is not located in the Alpena area but shares the city’s namesake. On Oct. 5, 1880, the steamboat Alpena left Grand Haven for Chicago with 80 passengers and 22 crew members.
The warm autumn night turned cold and stormy, with temperatures dropping below zero. The ship was destroyed in what the guide calls “the worst gale in Lake Michigan history,” known as “The Big Blow.” Wreckage was found along 70 miles of Michigan beaches, along with thousands of apples the steamboat had been carrying.
Some sailors still say they see the Alpena on misty nights in Lake Michigan. Visitors interested in hearing local stories firsthand are directed to Alpena Ghost Tours.