Eight candidates are competing for four seats on the Alpena Public Schools Board of Education, with the successful candidates scheduled to serve four-year terms beginning in January 2027 and ending in December 2030.
The field includes two incumbents, AJ MacArthur and Sarah Fritz, who are seeking second terms after serving their first terms. Evan Carlson, Kayla Ratz, Claire Kipfmiller, Lindsey Klein, Vincent Thomas and Robert Bruning are seeking their first terms. Responses from MacArthur, Klein, Thomas and Bruning addressed several issues likely to shape the district’s next board.
Literacy and student outcomes
The four candidates offered different approaches to improving literacy. Bruning proposed putting more money toward a mentoring program in which students would spend time reading with other students. If that did not work, he said he would consider changing the reading curriculum.
“I'd like to put a little more money towards a mentoring program,” Bruning said.
Klein said literacy depends on both schools and families. She supported more innovative programs, including family nights and possible involvement from organizations such as the Alpena Boys and Girls Club.
“I feel like the literacy rate isn't just on the school district,” Klein said.
MacArthur emphasized parents reading with their children at home. Thomas said parents need to be involved and that the district should begin focusing on reading early, particularly in kindergarten through second grade.
On the board’s role in student outcomes, MacArthur said curriculum decisions and ensuring that administrators and teachers have the necessary tools are among the board’s most important responsibilities. Thomas said the board should make decisions for constituents while keeping students first. Klein emphasized calm conversations and providing support and resources rather than assuming one person is responsible for a problem.
Staffing, transportation and school operations
Staff shortages were another major concern. Bruning said teachers are carrying responsibilities beyond classroom instruction and should receive more help. He also suggested retention bonuses for teachers every five years.
Klein said the district should examine whether pay is contributing to teacher shortages and cited survey results that, in her view, suggested teachers may be under sustained pressure. MacArthur described staffing difficulties as part of a broader problem involving demands placed on teachers by administrators and state and federal laws.
Thomas focused on bus drivers and support staff, saying schools cannot operate without them. He proposed more competitive incentives and longevity incentives, as well as training maintenance workers and custodians to serve as substitute bus drivers.
“You take our bus drivers and support staff, we won’t be having school,” Thomas said.
The candidates’ stated priorities reflected those concerns. Bruning listed reading and math proficiency, classroom security related to student misbehavior, and transportation. Klein cited community support, staff engagement, safety and retention, and a policy barring political discussion during the school day. MacArthur named fiscal responsibility, financial solvency and a long-term facilities plan. Thomas pointed to declining enrollment, unused buildings, staff shortages and student behavior.
Questions about the proposed bond
The candidates also discussed a proposed $29 million bond for district needs. Bruning said he wanted to review how money from the previous bond was spent, what remained, where it went and whether contracts for certain projects had been overpaid before deciding whether to support the new proposal.
Klein said she saw a need for the work and believed it could benefit the community, but said she would want to review documentation and confirm that policies and laws were followed. MacArthur said he dislikes taxes but understands why the proposal is being brought to voters. Thomas said he was not yet familiar enough with the bond to take a firm position, although he was not opposed if the work is needed.
“If the work needs to be done the work needs to be done. They are aging buildings,” Thomas said.
MacArthur said the board’s first term functioned as a team to keep the schools operating, although he did not believe he had championed a specific cause.
How the candidates define a nonpartisan board
Bruning said being nonpartisan means not being politically motivated by a party. Klein said board members may hold personal beliefs but must keep their role focused on dignity and respect for every student and staff member. MacArthur said he is not controlled by the Alpena County Republican Party and does not consult with it, while also saying personal values cannot simply be left outside the boardroom.
Thomas said political beliefs should not determine board decisions and that the board should rely on data and what is best for students.
Voters with questions can contact Bruning at [email protected] or through the Facebook page Committee to elect Robert Bruning to the APS Board. Klein can be reached at [email protected] or through Lindsey for Alpena Public School Board. MacArthur listed [email protected] as his school board email. Thomas can be contacted at [email protected] or through the Facebook page Committee to elect Vincent Thomas to the Alpena public School board.