Four of the eight candidates running for four Alpena Public Schools Board of Education seats are outlining different approaches to literacy, school finances, facilities and staffing as voters prepare to choose board members for terms beginning in January 2027.

The candidates—Evan Carlson, incumbent Cindy Fritz, Claire Kipfmiller and Kayla Ratz—answered questions from The Alpena News about student outcomes, the proposed $29 million bond, teacher and staff shortages, board communication and the meaning of a non-partisan school board race.

Different approaches to improving literacy

Carlson, a juvenile probation officer in Presque Isle County and a former Alpena Public Schools substitute teacher, said teachers have told him students need more behavioral support and smaller classes. He proposed a long-term investment that would cap class sizes at 24 students.

Fritz supports continuing the Benchmark Advance curriculum in kindergarten through fifth grade and using instructional coaches to help both new and experienced teachers with professional development.

Kipfmiller, a local business owner and parent of a first- and third-grader, said limiting classroom technology could improve attention and literacy while reducing technology replacement and upgrade costs. Ratz said the district should reduce the stigma around holding students back when they are not ready and reduce class sizes.

The candidates also described different priorities for working with district leadership. Carlson said board members should set aside personal and political egos, maintain civil conversations and be able to disagree without becoming disagreeable. Fritz said board members should listen to teachers and other employees who work directly with students.

Kipfmiller said she sees a gap in communication and wants board members to speak directly with people affected by decisions, including teachers and bus drivers. She proposed a regular newsletter in students’ Friday folders to update parents on board decisions and discussions. Ratz said she wants to be present beyond board meetings and help create a board that communicates with kindness and professionalism.

Bond questions and school priorities

The candidates differed over whether they currently support the proposed $29 million bond. Carlson and Ratz said they need more information about how the money would be spent before deciding. Kipfmiller said she would accept a higher tax if she knew the money was going to education, but also wants more details.

Fritz supports the bond, pointing to aging windows, heating and cooling systems, secure doors at ACES and the need to replace roughly 500 doors across district buildings. She also noted that she would pay for the bond alongside other community members.

The candidates’ top issues also varied. Carlson listed student outcomes, fiscal responsibility and school facilities. Fritz identified literacy and math scores, absenteeism and transportation for rural schools. Kipfmiller named free school meals, bullying prevention, student services, athletics and the arts. Ratz listed free meals, transportation, reading and math proficiency.

Staff shortages and non-partisan service

Staffing was described as a major concern by all four candidates. Carlson suggested negotiating with collective bargaining units to improve working conditions, paying out teachers’ unused sick days when they retire and creating more full-time opportunities for bus drivers by combining driving with instructional-assistant duties. He also said instructional assistants need higher pay.

Fritz cited a district teacher-retention figure that rose from 67% of first-year teachers in 2024 to 71.5%. She said continued staff surveys by Rehmann could help identify areas needing improvement.

Kipfmiller said shortages of teachers, bus drivers and janitors leave essential work without enough people to do it. She said the district should determine why staff members are struggling before developing solutions, while noting she did not know whether reports of retaliation against employees who raise concerns applied to Alpena.

Ratz said many teachers feel overwhelmed and that staffing shortages affect performance across every level of the staff.

On the non-partisan nature of the office, Carlson said school board candidates are not elected by political party, although candidates do not lose their personal values by running. He acknowledged running as a Democratic precinct delegate in the August primary but said the school board election is not about party politics.

Fritz said she is not endorsed by a political party and believes board members must find common ground for students, teachers and the school system. Kipfmiller said supporting a candidate is different from endorsing one and said she has received only personal donations from citizens. Ratz said personal political beliefs should not determine her hopes for improving Alpena schools.

Fritz said she is proud of helping introduce new math and English Language Arts curricula and instructional coaches during her first term. She also supports the superintendent’s strategic plan and the “reimagining the district” project with Kingscott.

Voters can contact Carlson through voteevancarlson.com, by phone at 989-590-3886 or at [email protected]. Fritz can be reached at [email protected]. Kipfmiller holds open hours from 9 to 11 a.m. Tuesdays and 3 to 5 p.m. Fridays at The Elixir Bar across from Kipfmiller Produce; she also lists [email protected] and 989-884-2335. Ratz is asking voters to contact her through the Kayla Ratz For APS School Board Facebook page.