Alpena Public Schools officials are reporting two challenges that could shape classroom work for years to come: more serious student behavior concerns and a growing number of children arriving at kindergarten below academic or social readiness benchmarks.
The issues were discussed Monday, Oct. 12, during the district’s annual Board of Education retreat. Members reviewed student data, progress on the strategic plan, behavior-management procedures, curriculum feedback and kindergarten screening results.
Behavior hearings and threat assessments
Superintendent Dave Rabbideau told the board the district has hired behavior consultants and other personnel to help teachers and staff respond to escalating behavior and de-escalate difficult situations.
“It just seems like every year, a fifth grade behavior in the past is now a fourth grade behavior, and the fourth grade behavior is a third and all the way down into kindergarten,” Rabbideau said. “We're seeing things that we've not seen before, and we're trying to be as proactive in dealing with those.”
Rabbideau presented a 10-year table of student behavior hearings handled by the superintendent. These hearings involve cases that could not be resolved at the building level and resulted in a long-term suspension of 10 days or more or an expulsion.
- 2016-2017: 13 hearings
- 2018-2019: 59 hearings
- 2020-2021: 14 hearings
- 2022-2023: 100 hearings
- 2025-2026: 44 hearings
The school year with 100 hearings followed the Oxford High School shooting. Rabbideau said the district treated threats seriously during that period, including possible copycat behavior, and said the need for threat-assessment procedures extended across Michigan and the nation.
Assistant Superintendent Stacy Moors also briefed the board on behavior threat assessment management, or BTAM. Michigan law requires public schools to maintain a threat-assessment protocol. Under the process, a team of at least three professionals—a mental-health professional, a school administrator and a law-enforcement professional—reviews a reported threat, organizes and analyzes information, completes documentation and develops a management plan when appropriate.
Not every report moves through the full process. Moors said a threat may be determined to be transient early in the review. The district has trained 27 administrators, 33 mental-health professionals and four law-enforcement officers. An administrator is always involved, while the superintendent is notified immediately in particularly serious cases. The number of people notified otherwise depends on the student’s circumstances and the level of support required.
Kindergarten readiness data raises concern
Rabbideau said Alpena children are entering kindergarten less ready than in previous years, describing kindergarten readiness as a problem nationwide. The district uses the Brigance assessment for incoming kindergarteners, measuring areas such as gross and fine motor skills, language, academic and cognitive development, self-help and social-emotional skills.
In 2025-2026, 52% of incoming kindergarteners were considered ready on the Brigance. In 2026-2027, the figure was 54%. This was the second year APS used the assessment.
The district also uses Acadience with incoming kindergarteners and first graders to assess foundational literacy and reading skills, including phonemic awareness, phonics, vocabulary and reading fluency. In 2025-2026, 60% of incoming kindergarteners tested below or well below benchmark, while 40% were at benchmark or above. The previous year’s results were evenly split at 50% and 50%.
The share of district kindergartners with individual reading improvement plans, or IRIPs, increased from 48.24% in 2022 to 64.46% in 2026. An IRIP is a written school plan outlining targeted reading interventions for a student with a reading deficiency or below-grade-level reading.
Ella White Elementary Principal Meaghan Black said students who begin kindergarten with larger academic and social gaps require more time and support, leaving teachers with less time to prepare them for first grade.
“Just to kind of extrapolate out, if they’re coming into us at that level of not being ready for kindergarten, think about then, the length that teachers need to go to get them ready for first grade, that’s a pretty heavy lift, and so you're moving into first grade with even greater gaps,” Black said.
Curriculum feedback and district business
Elementary teachers told the district that the math curriculum has appropriate pacing and engages students through Waggle and Math on the Spot videos. Paper-and-pencil assessments were also identified as a strength. Teachers reported gaps in number writing, pencil grip, teen numbers and number partners, along with technical problems with Waggle and a need for more curriculum training.
Teachers praised the University of Florida Literacy Institute Foundations English Language Arts curriculum for its weekly assessments, progress monitoring and letter-sound checks. They said writing conventions, vocabulary acquisition, and speaking and listening do not have equally formal or common assessments.
The district also received $3.1 million in 61v funding for Career and Technical Education programs. The money will support new CTE courses at the junior high and high school levels.
As part of discussions about a proposed $29 million no-mill bond, staff received facilities surveys seeking feedback on building conditions and needed improvements. Rabbideau also invited staff, families and community members to focus groups. The meetings are scheduled for the four Mondays following school board meetings on Oct. 19 and Oct. 26, with additional sessions at 5:30 p.m. on Nov. 2 and Nov. 9.
Board members unanimously approved a two-year Alpena Education Association agreement running through June 2028. Sarah Costain and AJ MacArthur were absent, while Eric Hansen abstained.