Four candidates won seats on the Alpena Public School Board of Education after a closely watched overnight count reshaped the race in its final hours. Evan Carlson, incumbent Sarah Fritz, Claire Kipfmiller and Kayla Ratz finished among the top four vote-getters in the election, according to results reported early Wednesday, Nov. 4, 2026.
The outcome followed months of campaigning that included knocking on doors, speaking with voters and explaining why each candidate believed they were the right choice for the board. The four successful candidates will begin their terms in January.
Late votes changed the order
The ranking shifted several times as ballots arrived and were tallied at the Alpena County Clerk's office. Incumbent AJ MacArthur appeared positioned to claim one of the four seats, but a batch of votes from Krakow Township and Presque Isle Township in Presque Isle County moved him out of the top four.
The final order of candidates, based on votes reported in Alpena County, Krakow Township and Presque Isle Township, was:
- Claire Kipfmiller: 6,584 votes
- Kayla Ratz: 6,094 votes
- Evan Carlson: 5,885 votes
- Sarah Fritz: 5,823 votes
- AJ MacArthur: 5,788 votes
- Lindsey Klein: 5,433 votes
- Robert Bruning: 5,396 votes
- Vincent Thomas: 4,780 votes
MacArthur, Klein, Bruning and Thomas did not receive enough votes to earn seats.
Winners react to the result
Kipfmiller said she learned about her victory after waking at 3 a.m. and being told the results by her husband. She went back to sleep, then woke to messages from supporters. She described the experience as surprising and said she was eager to begin working with the other board members.
“Waking back up and getting messages from just everybody being so excited was amazing,” Kipfmiller said.
She also said the result felt surreal and that she was ready to get started.
“Of course you always hope you're going to win,” she said. “I'm really looking forward to working with everybody. I'm ready to get in there and get started.”
Carlson said the race was closer than he wanted but credited his volunteer team, campaign work and consistent messaging for the win. He said voters supported his focus on students and the community.
“Voters agreed with my vision to put students first and remain community focused,” Carlson said.
Ratz said she was excited about the result and was looking ahead to January. Fritz thanked Alpena residents for their support and said she intended to continue supporting students, teachers and staff, along with the district's strategic plan.
“I would like to thank the Alpena community for trusting me again to represent the Alpena Public Schools,” Fritz said. “I will continue to support the students, teachers, and staff, and the strategic plan and help to ensure the future of the district.”