As Halloween gives way to Thanksgiving, lake trout and lake whitefish enter their fall spawning season in Lake Huron. Near Alpena, the seasonal fishery carries a story of recovery for wild lake trout—and a much more troubling outlook for whitefish.

Thunder Bay was once a major center for whitefish reproduction and remains home to several lake trout spawning sites. Both species also use artificial spawning reefs recently placed near the cement plant channel. But invasive zebra and quagga mussels have transformed the bay’s reefs since the 1990s, removing much of the food supply young whitefish depend on.

A 1992 discovery near Alpena

In mid-October 1992, Department of Natural Resources researchers lifted a net from a small natural rock reef about five miles offshore in Thunder Bay. The catch was mostly lake trout, along with some whitefish. Almost all of the lake trout were wild, with no fin clips or other marks showing that they had spent their early lives in a hatchery.

Those fish were the first wild, spawning lake trout recorded in Lake Huron since sea lampreys had wiped out the population in the 1940s. The discovery was tempered by the condition of the catch: most fish were small and covered with sea lamprey wounds.

One larger female was carrying eggs, but the eggs fell onto the boat deck when she was lifted from the net. A sea-lamprey attack had left a hole in her side. The damage illustrated a major reason Lake Huron’s lake trout recovered slowly: lampreys often target larger trout, killing them before they can spawn.

The Great Lakes Fishery Commission and resource agencies eventually addressed the lamprey problem by treating the St. Marys River, a major sea lamprey reproduction area. The Hammond Bay Biological Station north of Rogers City played an important role in that effort.

Why the reefs matter

Lake trout and whitefish both deposit their eggs on rock reefs, but the species use those sites differently. Lake trout gather at specific areas with especially suitable rock. Whitefish are less selective, scattering their eggs widely across a reef.

Whitefish produce many more eggs per female than lake trout, allowing them to be less precise about where the eggs land. Even so, a successful spawning reef needs more than rocks. It also requires excellent water quality, clean rock with spaces where eggs can settle and receive oxygenated water, and enough of the right food for newly hatched fish.

The eggs are laid in fall and do not hatch until about March. After hatching, the fry remain among the rocks while their yolk sacs provide nourishment. If sediment fills the spaces between rocks or the water loses oxygen, the eggs and fry can suffocate. That is why state agencies work to protect spawning reefs from dredging spoils and pollution.

Mussels changed the food web

Before about 1990, Thunder Bay had the key ingredients for productive trout and whitefish spawning. The arrival of zebra and quagga mussels changed that balance. The invasive mussels consume the tiny plankton that young whitefish eat after their yolk sacs are gone.

Whitefish hatch at less than half the length of a sewing needle and have mouths small enough to eat only the tiniest zooplankton. They also once depended heavily on Diporeia, a shrimp-like animal that numbered in the thousands per square yard in Thunder Bay. Diporeia disappeared quickly after the mussel invasion, leaving whitefish with far less food during their first years of life.

Lake trout have had more flexibility. They hatch larger, have relatively large mouths and can move beyond plankton to Diporeia or other small animals, including aquatic insects. That ability to switch food sources is one reason lake trout are slowly recovering in Lake Huron while whitefish are in steep decline.

From a regional whitefish source to a warning

Nearly 30 years ago, the DNR and partner agencies tagged whitefish at spawning sites across Lake Huron. Fish tagged near Sulfur Island and elsewhere in Thunder Bay were later reported from areas between Harrisville and the Upper Peninsula, as well as Ontario’s North Channel. The movements showed that Thunder Bay was once a primary whitefish source for Lake Huron, particularly its northern half.

That abundance has not returned. The source material says the bay’s former whitefish productivity can recover only if invasive mussels loosen their hold on Lake Huron’s food supply.

Residents and visitors can learn more about the region’s fishery history at the Besser Museum Fishery Heritage Exhibit next summer. The exhibit also connects to the work of Jim Johnson, who served as a research biologist at the DNR’s Alpena Fishery Station. The station’s research vessel, the RV Chinook, and boat captain Clarence “Tuffy” Cross later retired to the Besser Museum.