Forty-five years ago, Alpena Public Schools faced a crisis that brought the district to a standstill: on Oct. 16, 1981, the district closed its schools after three local millage proposals failed.
The shutdown, remembered as “Black Friday,” affected 6,855 students and most district employees. Schools reopened two weeks later only after voters approved a fourth millage on Oct. 30. Students returned Nov. 3, 1981, but the district’s financial problems did not disappear with the reopening.
Why Alpena schools closed
The district was forced to close because it could not meet its financial obligations. At the time, Alpena was among school systems struggling with a gap between the state’s per-pupil funding and the cost of educating students.
Betty Werth, who reported for The Alpena News during the crisis, described the conflict as a clash between schools needing additional money and property owners who were exhausted by rising taxes. She said school districts across Michigan were also trying and failing to pass millages.
“It was a very difficult time for schools who were struggling financially,” Werth said. “And a difficult time for property owners whose property taxes kept going up and up.”
John Taylor was Alpena Public Schools superintendent when the closure occurred. According to earlier reporting cited by The News, the only district employees on duty during the shutdown were Taylor, two janitors and three secretaries. About 500 full-time staff members were laid off.
The closure drew attention beyond Alpena. Werth said Alpena was the first of several school districts nationally to shut down because of financial problems, and the district’s situation became the subject of statewide and national coverage.
Reopening did not restore normal school life
The millage approved Oct. 30 allowed classes to resume, but the district reopened without transportation. Students also could not take electives or participate in sports. Missed school days were made up during the following summer.
The loss of bus service disrupted families and students and contributed to a recall effort targeting the school board. Werth said the consequences continued long after the doors reopened.
“The repercussions echoed for a long time,” Werth said.
The shutdown also divided Alpena County. Past reporting described stronger support for the school board in the city, while residents in rural parts of the county were less supportive. A group called United Public Voice, or UPV, formed to oppose the millage proposals and the board.
State officials did not offer a bailout. State School Superintendent Phillip Runkel visited Alpena and promoted a “no state bail-out” message. The state also was dealing with Taylor and Pontiac school districts, which were described as being near financial ruin. A loan was considered impossible because the state had no money to lend and Alpena had no ability to repay it.
Former Gov. William Milliken said the district’s future depended on the district itself, warning that helping Alpena could prompt similar requests from other school systems.
Letters, football and the final day
The financial dispute played out in letters to The News. Elizabeth Connolly wrote that the national publicity was damaging to Alpena’s reputation while urging continued support for local students. Special education teacher Lynn Hartman described her workload at the junior high, saying she taught 19 students individually and prepared 23 lesson plans each day.
Other letters reflected residents’ anger over taxes, inflation and district spending. Lorna Litzner wrote that many local residents were unemployed or had low incomes and argued that higher taxes were unacceptable. She also criticized a separation or severance arrangement involving an employee identified as Mr. Meeder, $40,000 spent on computerized bus routes and the lack of administrative cuts. The article said that $40,000 would equal about $142,580 in today’s dollars.
The final school day coincided with Alpena High School’s homecoming football game. Alpena lost 35-0, according to previous reporting, as students, parents, players and fans marked both the end of the shortened 1981 season and the temporary end of school.
Students reportedly wore black armbands. About 200 students gathered before the game at the front oval of Alpena High School for a ceremony in which a black banner was draped over the school nameplate. A “for sale” sign was placed in the central planter, and large letters spelling “closed” were put in school windows.
The shutdown was especially painful for seniors. Dawn Fitch, reflecting on the final football game and the loss of school, said the band had worked hard that year and that she felt a deep sense of loss.
Some students later moved to other districts and did not return. Nearby parochial schools and the districts in Hillman, Posen, Rogers City and Alcona received enrollment inquiries, but past reporting said those schools could not—or would not—take large numbers of Alpena students.
In a poem about homecoming and the shutdown, Alpena High student Kim Beyer ended with an image that captured the uncertainty of the moment: “A blowing paper / Nothing more / Our hopes and dreams / Behind closed doors.”